(PLL 1x01) The girls wake-up to find Ali is missing, but Spencer isn't there either. She shows up as they're leaving. (PLL 3x01) The girls wake-up to find Emily is missing, but Spencer isn't there either. She shows up as they're leaving. (PLL 1x01) When the girls wake up and find Spencer and Ali missing they head outside and find Spencer. Spencer tells them a bunch of stuff in a real wooden voice. We know Troian can act much better than that so why would she do that. Perhaps Spencer was emotionally distraught after murdering and burying Ali. (PLL Analysis 01) Ali tells Spencer that in the pilot she sent Spencer to bed after Spencer followed her. While this may be true, Spencer was still up and about when the other girls woke up. Spencer tells the other girls that she thinks she heard Ali scream, but that doesn't make sense. The girls would have immediately rushed out to see and not found anything. Between the time that Ali got murdered and Spencer talked to the girls, Mrs. DiLaurentis would have had to bury Ali and Ms. Grunwald would have had to have dug her up. It would make more sense if Spencer had a psychotic break between the time Ali was murdered and Spencer talked to the other girls. (PLL Analysis 02) Why did Mrs. DiLaurentis blame Spencer? Ali says that her mother would have seen the person strike her with a rock (how did Ali see that the person had a rock and not a shovel?). So if Mrs. D saw Ali's murderer, and it wasn't Spencer, why did she continue to blame Spencer? (PLL 2x25) "You're not the only genius in this car Spencer." No, but she is A genius. (PLL 3x01) Somebody called Emily from Spencer's phone the night of the "Great Muppet Corpse Caper." Yes, somebody did. Spencer did. We've seen Spencer building a Mona-A timeline. Is that really what it is or is that her keeping track of what SHE'S doing? She's never shown it to anybody else. Even if it is a Mona-A timeline she could be doing that just to keep her side of the story straight. -Reimagine the "Hallway Scene" with Spencer as A and Paige working with her. Spencer is telling Paige "I know who you are so do what I tell you." Paige tells Spencer "I won't let you and the rest of the A-Team hurt Emily." (PLL 3x11) Spencer decides to fully set Paige up when Paige decides to go off-script. This was the change of plans Mona was referring to. (PLL 3x11) Mona says that Paige has Maya's phone. When did she get it? When Spencer was rifling through her bag and just happened to find the earring. (PLL 3x12) Spencer spots the lit up cabin to keep the Liars there just a little bit longer. (PLL 3x13) Spencer comes out of a cabin by herself. There's no scene with her and Toby in a cabin and nobody follows her out. What was she doing in there? (PLL 3x13) Garrett tells Spencer he has information about the night that Ali dies. Spencer doesn't have him come with her to find the other girls. She has him stay where he is alone, away from the girls. Garrett then winds up dead. -Halloween Episode: Spencer and Paige talk to each other after Emily updates Paige on the situation (no, not that doofus from Jersey Shore.). If Paige works for Spencer than this scene makes even more sense. They're talking about how they've resolved things on the A-Team. (PLL 3x14) Mona and Spencer are going through an A power struggle. This is why the Queen of Hearts attacks Spencer on the train, and Toby is trying to run down the other A. It also explains Spencer's increasing paranoia. (PLL 3x14) Spencer knows how to pick locks. (PLL 3x15) Spencer, Emily, and Hannah go into the school janitor's office to find Ali's diary. Emily fumbles for several moments unable to find the light switch, but Spencer goes right to it. (PLL 3x16) Ali tells Aria, "You see A everywhere you turn. You all do. I'm suprised Spencer hasn't figured that out." Spencer is everywhere with the girls. (PLL 3x18) Mona-A and Spencer-A: "You're a little off your A-game." "This is not a game to me." "It would be a shame if Toby went all that way for you and ended up cheering just for me." (PLL 3x18) Emily receives a postcard from A in French. Who do we know that speaks French? Spencer. (PLL 3x20) BIG CLUE. When Spencer feels guilty she buries things. Like crystal paper weights, hockey sticks, shovels,...and dead best friends. (PLL 4x01) Red Coat wipes Mona's computer. The only person we know that's had access to that computer besides Mona is Spencer. A virus placed on it, activated by phone, and boom goes the dynamite. (PLL 4x12) The liars find A's lair, and in it is a timeline covering all of them. There's only one person I know of in the series who makes timelines. Spencer. (PLL 4x15) The writers/showrunners of PLL love their little allusions...so: Notice who has the shovel (the weapon used to beat Ali to death)? (PLL 4x16) At the end of the episode the Risen Mitten knows that Ali and Shanna used to be friends. How did it know? The only person Shanna told was Emily...who then told the Liars including Spencer. (credit: Lelly Parker) (PLL 4x17) Emily shuts Spencer out, and A suddenly goes crazy on Emily in the school. Spencer doesn't like being shut out. (PLL 4x19) Basically every comment Ali makes to Spencer is saying that Spencer killed Ali. (PLL 4x20) Where was Spencer so that she couldn't get to the Snake House on time? Might she have been wearing a black hoodie and picking up pages of a manuscript? (PLL 4x20) How did the fake Spencer know to wear a blonde wig? Only three people would have been in on that detail: Emily, Hanna, and Spencer. (PLL 4x20) We find out that Spencer was addicted to amphetamines two years ago. This would have aligned with the time that Ali was murdered. Was Spencer having black outs and sleep-walking back then too? (credit: Heather Hogan) (PLL 5x04) The conversation between Spencer and Ali didn't actually happen. It was all in Spencer's mind. That's why she told Hanna, "I just talked to Ali and she didn't say anything about a recording." That's also why Spencer just happened to cut herself so that she could find the heart medication. She already knew what killed Mrs. D, and where it was. #SpencerIsCocoaForCuckoopuffs (PLL 5x05) Jenna at the end of the episode doesn't look at all torn up about Shana's death. If that's true then she had to be faking when Aria came around. In order to do that she would have had to know that Aria was coming. Aria only told three people: Hanna and Emily at school, and Spencer when she went by before going to Jenna's. One of them had to tell Jenna that Aria was coming. (PLL 5x09-10) A steals Alison's doctor recording from Spencer's secret spot in her chair. Very few people know where this is, not even the other Liars know about it. (PLL 5x22) A targets Mike after Aria tells the other Liars, including Spencer, that he can clear Alison. (PLL 5x22) Spencer could easily have put the blood in her own purse. In fact, that makes more sense than she didn't notice it in there for 24hrs. (PLL 5x23) Spencer, Aria, and Emily search Mona's room and find a notecard with several anagrams of Charles DiLaurentis. Not only did Spencer easily find it, but later when they find Mona she has no idea who Charles is. (PLL 5x26) It's the girls first night in the dollhouse, and A is watching them on the cameras. All of the girls fit in, but Spencer's screen doesn't make sense. In the next scene it shows her sprawled and easily visible on her bed, but you can't see her on her screen. (PLL 5x26) "Charles" comes up next to Spencer in the vault, but when Spencer is distracted he gets away with unbelievable speed...if he wasn't just a figment of Spencer's madness. (PLL 6x06) Sara is hit by a car that seems to be Lesli's, but Hanna had stolen Lesli's car. However, Spencer was with her when this happened, and could have commendered the car.